It was just a bag in the water. But it was a large white plastic bag, one flap of which protruded above the surface of Little Pine Lake in our Minnesota Study Area. As Evrett, Isaac, and I paddled across the southern end of Little Pine to begin our observations of the Dream Island loon pair, the bag caught our eye and sullied the otherwise idyllic Northwoods scene. Looking to leave the lake a bit cleaner than when we had arrived, we fished the bag out of the water.

The writing on the bag told the story.

I have a confession to make. I come from a family of non-gardeners. When we see a beautiful tree or flower, we savor it. But the notion that some act of ours might alter the health or appearance of a plant is altogether foreign. A product of suburbs of large cities, I have grown accustomed to gazing at the verdant, manicured lawns and gardens of neighbors — then turning to look ruefully at my own. Yet jealousy of my neighbors’ lawns is not enough to induce me to follow their lead.

Of course, the suburbs are one thing. Lakeshores are quite another. The bag that Evrett fished out of Little Pine suggested that a resident on Little Pine was placing fertilizer on their lawn. While the decision of how to treat one’s lakeshore is up to each individual, it has consequences for all of us. Inevitably some of the high-nitrogen and -phosphorous fertilizer that produces a lush green lawn by the lake washes into the lake when it rains. Lake phytoplankton — free-floating, microscopic algae that inhabit all lakes — are starved for nitrogen and phosphorous just like grasses and trees on land. So adding fertilizer to lakes causes higher-than-normal growth of phytoplankton, which reduces water clarity and can have a variety of more serious impacts on lake-dwelling animals and plants.

It is too early to tell whether lawn fertilizer is at the root of the water clarity loss in the Upper Midwest during the past quarter century. We do know that heavy rainfall causes low water clarity. And we know that low water clarity hinders loon parents’ feeding efforts and produces emaciated chicks. But while we investigate the specific cause of water clarity decline, wouldn’t it be prudent for lake residents to stop using fertilizer on lakeside lawns, in case loon chicks are unintended victims?

_____________________________________________________________________

By the way, Wisconsin Public Radio did a short segment on our study and on the decline in water clarity we have reported recently. If you wish to hear how I sound after a day of field work and a bit too much coffee, you can find it at this link.